The Boxing Tribune

Boxing's Independent Media

  • Home
  • News
  • Videos
  • Best Of
  • Staff
  • Advertise With Us
  • Write for Us

Diaz vs. Malignaggi II: Is It Diaz’s Turn To Be Screwed?

December 10, 2009 by Paul Magno Leave a Comment

0
SHARES
ShareTweet


by Paul Magno

First, I’m not of the opinion that Paulie was robbed in the first fight. The Gale Van Hoy score of 118-110 for Diaz was obscene, but the fight itself was close and could’ve gone either way.

And now, as both fighters gear up for the rematch of their August encounter, the stage is being set for another controversial decision that is almost guaranteed to lead to a third encounter. All judging issues aside, the match-up itself screams controversy.

Malignaggi is a quick, feather-fisted stylist while Diaz is a light-hitting, overstuffed lightweight pressure fighter. Both fighters execute their styles perfectly.

Generally speaking, some judges value style and defense while other more readily score aggression and fighters who come forward. With neither fighter having enough power to change the course of the fight, Diaz-Malignaggi is always going to be a recipe for diverse scoring that depends on one’s own judging aesthetic and criteria.

Have them fight one hundred times, they’ll have the same fight one hundred times and, depending on the judges, there could be one hundred different decisions. It’s simply a pairing that’s always going to tell you more about the judge’s line of thought than either fighter’s respective ability.

Now, having said that and established the fact that Diaz-Malignaggi will always be a tough fight to call, the heat brought into the rematch just may have ensured a Malignaggi win and yet another controversy.

Malignaggi’s rant after the first bout was one of the most memorable moments of the year for HBO and his heartfelt accusations are still reverberating throughout the boxing world. Don’t think for a second that the assigned judges for the rematch will be immune to the pressures created by the controversy surrounding the first bout.

It may be the case that all three judges will come into the bout focused and fair and ready to take an even-handed approach to their jobs. It’s just as likely, though, that Malignaggi, as the perceived victim, will get the benefit of the doubt on close rounds a lot more than he did the first time.

Then, consider that judge Mauro Di Fiore is a local Chicago judge with little experience outside of Illinois and that one of the other judges, Tom Miller, is no stranger to controversy himself after scoring Chris John-Rocky Juarez I a draw.

The end result of this Saturday’s contest is bound to have some controversy behind it unless one of the fighters can significantly up their game enough to make the judging process more than just a contest of personal judging criteria. But don’t count on it.

Instead, get ready for some more boxing judge controversy and losing fighter pathos. And prepare yourself for part 3.



Your Ad Here

Paul Magno on Email
Paul Magno
Paul Magno
Paul Magno has over thirty-five years of experience in and around the sport of boxing and has had his hand in everything, from officiating to training. As a writer, his work has appeared in Yahoo Sports, Fox Sports, Inside Fights, The Boxing Tribune, Fight Hype, Man Cave Magazine, Bleacher Report, and The Queensberry Rules.

Filed Under: Uncategorized Tagged With: Paulie Malignaggi, The Boxing Tribune

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Best of The Boxing Tribune

Canelo, Golden Boy Still Taking Steps Backwards With Chavez Fight

Canelo, Golden Boy Still Taking Steps Backwards With Chavez Fight

De La Hoya’s flaws lead to failure in Haymon lawsuit

De La Hoya’s flaws lead to failure in Haymon lawsuit

Kell Brook Loses In the Fourth Round To P4P King Terence Crawford

Kell Brook Loses In the Fourth Round To P4P King Terence Crawford

Boxing’s Weight Game: Our Legalized Cheat, Magno’s Monday Rant

Boxing’s Weight Game: Our Legalized Cheat, Magno’s Monday Rant

Boxing is my Passion (Second Version)

Boxing is my Passion (Second Version)

More of The Boxing Tribune's Best

Follow Us

Facebooktwitteryoutube

Alexa Traffic Rank

Sportsbook odds for all Boxing matches

Search

Recent

  • RIP Ted Sares: All Bull, No Bullshit
  • The Mental and Physical Benefits of Boxing
  • Interesting Similarities Between Boxing and eSports
  • 5 Boxing Rules Every Boxer Should Always Follow.
  • HOW TO GET STARTED IN BOXING